The Best Pizza in San Francisco
What is the best pizza in San Francisco?
By consensus across 5 independent sources, Tony's Pizza Napoletana, Golden Boy Pizza, Flour + Water Pizzeria lead the pizza ranking in San Francisco.
How the consensus ranking works →The ranking
Tony's Pizza NapoletanaⓘWhere it’s ranked
MICHELIN · Rec · Eater · Infatuation · r/sf #2
13-time World Pizza Champion Tony Gemignani's flagship — seven pizza styles from seven ovens, and an STG Margherita capped at 73 a day.
Golden Boy PizzaⓘWhere it’s ranked
Eater · Infatuation · SF Standard #3 · r/sf #1
The default SF square slice since 1978. Locals' outright #1 in nearly every thread — it just doesn't have the Michelin nod the two leaders do.
Flour + Water PizzeriaⓘWhere it’s ranked
MICHELIN · Rec · Eater · Infatuation
The pizza spinoff of one of SF's benchmark pasta houses — blistered Neapolitan-ish pies, recognized by MICHELIN.
MontesacroⓘWhere it’s ranked
MICHELIN · Rec · Eater · Infatuation
SF's pinsa specialist — the oval, airy Roman flatbread — and a MICHELIN-recognized room.
Outta Sight PizzaⓘWhere it’s ranked
Eater · Infatuation · SF Standard #7 · r/sf #3
The current local darling for a proper NY-style slice — a top-comment favorite across recent threads.
Gioia PizzeriaⓘWhere it’s ranked
Eater · Infatuation · r/sf #5
Thin, crackly, New York-leaning pies with a loyal local following.
Square Pie GuysⓘWhere it’s ranked
Eater · Infatuation · SF Standard #8 · r/sf #7
The city's go-to for Detroit-style — crispy, cheese-laced edges in a caramelized frame.
DamnfineⓘWhere it’s ranked
Eater · Infatuation · SF Standard #1
SF Standard's panel put it at #1 — a sourdough-crust newcomer that critics love, even if it hasn't hit the local-thread canon yet.
Pizzetta 211ⓘWhere it’s ranked
Eater · Infatuation · SF Standard #10 · r/sf #10
A tiny Outer Richmond institution doing small-batch, seasonal, farmers-market-driven pies.
PizzaHackerⓘWhere it’s ranked
Eater · Infatuation · r/sf #11
A Bernal favorite born from a backyard-oven obsession — charred, naturally-leavened pies.