Photo: Bay Area Reviews / Google77#5
★ #5 · Best Pizza in San Francisco
Outta Sight Pizza
Tenderloin · $ · Pizza · 4 sources · Updated freshness pending
Why it's #5
The current local darling for a proper NY-style slice — a top-comment favorite across recent threads.
Backed by 4 independent sources across 2 kinds of judge — critics, MICHELIN, and locals.
What to order
- 01Cheese slice
- 02Pepperoni slice
Where it's ranked
“The Tenderloin can call itself a pizzaiolo destination now thanks to Eric Ehler's shop at 422 Larkin.”
“Nails every element necessary for a perfect slice.”
“The best and one of the only spots in SF for a slice reminiscent of NYC pizza culture.”
Ranked #3 by locals across r/sf, r/bayarea and r/AskSF threads.
Good to know
Neighborhood
Tenderloin
Price
$
Cuisine
Pizza
Consensus rank
#5 of 10
Sources
4 across 2 kinds of judge
Updated
freshness pending
Distinctions
—
Locals want to go
485
Consensus score
77 / 100
More of the best Pizza in San Francisco
Round up the crew.
Save it to your list, or turn it into an actual plan — pick a night, invite friends, lock it in.
485 locals want to go here
Free · no account needed to save